Effects of rumen protected choline chloride in dairy cows
Jahrestagung der BAT e.V., October 2013
Jahrestagung der BAT e.V., October 2013
Trial results show that the use of protected choline is a preventive measurement for avoidance of fatty liver syndrome and ketosis around calving (Lima et al. 2007; Zom et al. 2011) and may improve milk production and reproduction parameters (Piepenbrink and Overton, 2003; Cooke et al. 2007). Aim of the trial was to examine the effect of rumen protected choline chloride on milk production and the incidence for ketosis in dairy cows under practical conditions.
Hence, two practical trials were carried out in 2012 in the Netherlands, first a more comprehensive trial, followed by a practical approach at a second farm. In trial 1 (farm with in total 250 cows, lactating cows kept in 4 different groups, 1 automatic milking system per group) 90 multiparous fresh cows (from fresh cow group up to 100 days in milk) were followed up from calving to 90 days in milk, 45 as control and 45 as choline treatment. After calving fresh cows were randomly assigned to the control (no supplementation) or choline treatment. Choline (60 g/cow/day of a product containing 25% choline chloride) was supplied via a mineral feed dispenser at the milking robot to only treatment animals. Advantage of this system was keeping all cows in the same group by reducing external factors to a minimum. Milk performance was recorded on daily basis and milk composition once a month. Body condition scores of all cows were measured on day 7-10 after calving and at trial end by a veterinarian. No differences on BCS (average value 2.9, resp.) were obtained between treatments at trial start (Scale 1-5; 1 = thin, no fat reserves; 5 = fat, high fat reserves). Ketone bodies in urine of all cows were measured on day 7-10 after calving by the same veterinarian by the use of test stripes and scaled from 1-6 (1 = no ketones, 6 = extreme levels of ketones).
Trial 2 was carried out at a farm with in total 90 cows. Focus was on the fresh cows (fresh cow group up to 120 days in milk) by comparing the effect of a 4 weeks choline supplementation with historical data from that farm. The same choline product was used with a dosage of 50 g/cow/day (direct inclusion to the mixing wagon).
For statistical evaluation (only trial 1) lactation curves were modelled as a function of day in milk and thus a “random regression model” was used with (1) fixed regression coefficients (course of milk per group and test day) and (2) random regression coefficients (course of milk per animal with unstructured covariance matrix and residual effect) for the similar parameter. As regression approach the Ali & Schaeffer model was used. Additionally, a fixed test day effect was in included (details of the evaluation method, see Mielenz et al. 2006).
In trial 1 the supplementation of rumen protected choline didn’t significantly influence milk yield within the first 90 days in lactation (table 1), but differences between treatments increased numerically over the entire trial period and the choline group peaked higher and kept the highest production over a longer period (graph 1). Milk protein concentrations were similar between both treatments but supplementation of choline resulted in a significantly reduced milk fat concentration within the first 30 days in lactation and therefore also milk fat/protein ratio (signal for lower risk for subclinical ketosis) differed significantly in this period (table 1 and graph 2). The same tendency was measured for fat/protein quotient (not shown). It was also measured that the number of cows with an elevated fat/protein ratio above 1.25 (indication of ketosis) declined by the supplementation of choline. The percentage of cows was reduced from 50.0% in control to 35.3% in choline group (day 1-30) and from 35.3% to 19.4% (day 31-60), respectively. Cows supplemented with choline showed a numerically reduced ketone body concentration in urine (2.22±1.40 vs. 2.62±1.66 in control; P=0.34) from which the conclusion can be drawn that together with the lower fat and fat/protein ratio this can be seen as a sign for reduced incidence for ketosis. Body condition score was not influenced on average (2.71±0.17 in choline; 2.61±0.16 in control; P=0.39) but a significant influence of time (lactation day) was detected as well as a tendency of treatment and time in favour to the choline supplementation for a higher BCS (P=0.13).
In trial 2 (table 2) feeding rumen protected choline resulted after 4 weeks in a reduced amount of cows “at risk” (too high milk fat/protein ratio) which was almost reduced by half. Also fewer animals were observed with a high ketone body concentration in milk. These results, although only compared with the historical data, confirm very well the results of the first experiment.
Rumen protected choline is a preventive measurement against fatty liver syndrome and ketosis after calving. In two trials rumen protected choline was used to proof the effects described in literature under practical conditions. In trial 1, feeding rumen protected choline didn’t influence milk yield but levels of ketone bodies in urine, fat concentration and fat/protein ratio in milk were reduced esp. within the first month of lactation which can be considered as a lower incidence for subclinical ketosis. The results of the 1st trial were confirmed in a practical approach where in contrast to historical results fewer cows showed symptoms of ketosis.
Your privacy
We use cookies to collect and analyse information on site performance and usage, to provide social media features and to enhance and customise content and advertisements.
About cookies on this site
Cookies used on the site are categorized and below you can read about each category and allow or deny some or all of them. When categories than have been previously allowed are disabled, all cookies assigned to that category will be removed from your browser. Additionally you can see a list of cookies assigned to each category and detailed information in the cookie declaration.
Necessary cookies
Some cookies are required to provide core functionality. The website won't function properly without these cookies and they are enabled by default and cannot be disabled.
CookieHub is a Consent Management Platform (CMP) which allows users to control storage and processing of personal information.
Cloudflare is a global network designed to make everything you connect to the Internet secure, private, fast, and reliable.
Preferences
Preference cookies enables the web site to remember information to customize how the web site looks or behaves for each user. This may include storing selected currency, region, language or color theme.
Analytical cookies
Analytical cookies help us improve our website by collecting and reporting information on its usage.
Google Analytics is a web analytics service offered by Google that tracks and reports website traffic.
Vimeo, Inc. is an American video hosting, sharing, services provider, and broadcaster. Vimeo focuses on the delivery of high-definition video across a range of devices.
HubSpot is a CRM platform that provides tools for marketing, sales, and customer service.
Marketing cookies
Marketing cookies are used to track visitors across websites to allow publishers to display relevant and engaging advertisements. By enabling marketing cookies, you grant permission for personalized advertising across various platforms.
Google Ads is an advertising service by Google for businesses that want to display ads on Google search results and its advertising network.
A piece of code that lets businesses measure, optimise and build audiences for advertising campaigns.
Cookies used on the site are categorized and below you can read about each category and allow or deny some or all of them. When categories than have been previously allowed are disabled, all cookies assigned to that category will be removed from your browser. Additionally you can see a list of cookies assigned to each category and detailed information in the cookie declaration.
Necessary cookies
Some cookies are required to provide core functionality. The website won't function properly without these cookies and they are enabled by default and cannot be disabled.
Name | Hostname | Vendor | Expiry |
---|---|---|---|
__cf_bm | .vimeo.com | Cloudflare, Inc. | 1 hour |
The __cf_bm cookie supports Cloudflare Bot Management by managing incoming traffic that matches criteria associated with bots. The cookie does not collect any personal data, and any information collected is subject to one-way encryption. | |||
__hssrc | .orffa.com | HubSpot | Session |
This cookie name is associated with websites built on the HubSpot platform. Whenever HubSpot changes the session cookie, this cookie is also set to determine if the visitor has restarted their browser. If this cookie does not exist when HubSpot manages cookies, it is considered a new session. | |||
__hssc | .orffa.com | HubSpot | 1 hour |
This cookie name is associated with websites built on the HubSpot platform. This cookie keeps track of sessions. This is used to determine if HubSpot should increment the session number and timestamps in the __hstc cookie. It contains the domain, viewCount (increments each pageView in a session), and session start timestamp. | |||
__cf_bm | .hubspot.com | Cloudflare, Inc. | 1 hour |
The __cf_bm cookie supports Cloudflare Bot Management by managing incoming traffic that matches criteria associated with bots. The cookie does not collect any personal data, and any information collected is subject to one-way encryption. | |||
cookiehub | .orffa.com | CookieHub | 365 days |
Used by CookieHub to store information about whether visitors have given or declined the use of cookie categories used on the site. | |||
_cfuvid | .hubspot.com | HubSpot | Session |
Used by Cloudflare WAF to distinguish individual users who share the same IP address and apply rate limits | |||
_cfuvid | .hsforms.com | HubSpot | Session |
Used by Cloudflare WAF to distinguish individual users who share the same IP address and apply rate limits | |||
_cfuvid | .vimeo.com | HubSpot | Session |
Used by Cloudflare WAF to distinguish individual users who share the same IP address and apply rate limits | |||
__cf_bm | .hsforms.net | Cloudflare, Inc. | 1 hour |
The __cf_bm cookie supports Cloudflare Bot Management by managing incoming traffic that matches criteria associated with bots. The cookie does not collect any personal data, and any information collected is subject to one-way encryption. | |||
__cf_bm | .hsforms.com | Cloudflare, Inc. | 1 hour |
The __cf_bm cookie supports Cloudflare Bot Management by managing incoming traffic that matches criteria associated with bots. The cookie does not collect any personal data, and any information collected is subject to one-way encryption. | |||
__cf_bm | .hs-scripts.com | Cloudflare, Inc. | 1 hour |
The __cf_bm cookie supports Cloudflare Bot Management by managing incoming traffic that matches criteria associated with bots. The cookie does not collect any personal data, and any information collected is subject to one-way encryption. | |||
__cf_bm | .hsadspixel.net | Cloudflare, Inc. | 1 hour |
The __cf_bm cookie supports Cloudflare Bot Management by managing incoming traffic that matches criteria associated with bots. The cookie does not collect any personal data, and any information collected is subject to one-way encryption. | |||
__cf_bm | .hs-banner.com | Cloudflare, Inc. | 1 hour |
The __cf_bm cookie supports Cloudflare Bot Management by managing incoming traffic that matches criteria associated with bots. The cookie does not collect any personal data, and any information collected is subject to one-way encryption. | |||
__cf_bm | .hs-analytics.net | Cloudflare, Inc. | 1 hour |
The __cf_bm cookie supports Cloudflare Bot Management by managing incoming traffic that matches criteria associated with bots. The cookie does not collect any personal data, and any information collected is subject to one-way encryption. |
Preferences
Preference cookies enables the web site to remember information to customize how the web site looks or behaves for each user. This may include storing selected currency, region, language or color theme.
Name | Hostname | Vendor | Expiry |
---|---|---|---|
vuid | .vimeo.com | 400 days | |
These cookies are used by the Vimeo video player on websites. |
Analytical cookies
Analytical cookies help us improve our website by collecting and reporting information on its usage.
Name | Hostname | Vendor | Expiry |
---|---|---|---|
_ga_ | .orffa.com | 400 days | |
Contains a unique identifier used by Google Analytics 4 to determine that two distinct hits belong to the same user across browsing sessions. | |||
_ga | .orffa.com | 400 days | |
Contains a unique identifier used by Google Analytics to determine that two distinct hits belong to the same user across browsing sessions. | |||
__hstc | .orffa.com | HubSpot | 180 days |
This cookie name is associated with websites built on the HubSpot platform. This is the main cookie for tracking visitors. It contains the domain, utk, initial timestamp (first visit), last timestamp (last visit), current timestamp (this visit), and session number (increments for each subsequent session). | |||
hubspotutk | .orffa.com | HubSpot | 180 days |
This cookie name is associated with websites built on the HubSpot platform. This cookie is used to keep track of a visitor's identity. This cookie is passed to HubSpot on form submission and used when deduplicating contacts. |
Marketing cookies
Marketing cookies are used to track visitors across websites to allow publishers to display relevant and engaging advertisements. By enabling marketing cookies, you grant permission for personalized advertising across various platforms.
Name | Hostname | Vendor | Expiry |
---|---|---|---|
_gcl_au | .orffa.com | Google Advertising Products | 90 days |
Used by Google AdSense to understand user interaction with the website by generating analytical data. | |||
_fbp | .orffa.com | Meta Platforms | 90 days |
Facebook Pixel advertising first-party cookie. Used by Facebook to track visits across websites to deliver a series of advertisement products such as real time bidding from third party advertisers. | |||
IDE | .doubleclick.net | Google Advertising Products | 390 days |
Used by Google's DoubleClick to serve targeted advertisements that are relevant to users across the web. Targeted advertisements may be displayed to users based on previous visits to a website. These cookies measure the conversion rate of ads presented to the user. |